vs
Blue Buffalo vs Holistic Select

Blue Buffalo vs. Holistic Select

In this comparison article for Blue Buffalo vs Holistic Select, we'll highlight the key differences between these two pet food brands. To properly compare Blue Buffalo and Holistic Select, we'll use up-to-date nutritional and price information.

There are many factors to consider when choosing the best pet food brand for your pet. Factors such as ingredient quality, guaranteed analysis, product safety, brand history, and cost are among the most important factors to consider.

Throughout this Holistic Select vs Blue Buffalo comparison, we've utilized average data to make general comparisons. If you'd like to see individual product reviews, visit our Blue Buffalo Review Page or Holistic Select Review Page.

Guaranteed Analysis: Holistic Select vs. Blue Buffalo

According to AAFCO, all pet food labels must provide a guaranteed analysis of nutrient content. The analysis must provide guaranteed minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat, and maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture.

All percentages used in this comparison are averages reported on a dry matter basis.

Blue Buffalo Dog Food vs. Holistic Select Dog Food

Dry Dog Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Crude Protein 30.6% 31.4%
Crude Fat 15.6% 15.9%
Crude Fiber 6.7% 5.8%
Wet/Canned Dog Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Crude Protein 41.3% 53.8%
Crude Fat 26.0% 28.0%
Crude Fiber 7.1% 4.9%

Crude Protein Comparison For Dog Food

Dogs require twenty-two amino acids to sustain life. Twelve of these amino acids are synthesized naturally, the remaining ten are consumed. Protein is the nutrient which provides some or all of these ten essential amino acids.

As you can see, Blue Buffalo and Holistic Select guarantee a similar amount of crude protein. For wet dog foods, Holistic Select provides significantly more protein (about 12.50% more).


Crude Fat Comparison For Dog Food

Like protein, fats are an essential part of a dog's body. Fats are needed for the proper development and function of the canine body.

Blue Buffalo and Holistic Select both provide roughly the same amount of crude fat. With regards to wet dog food, Holistic Select and Blue Buffalo also provide roughly the same amount of crude fat.


There is a relatively insignificant difference between the crude fiber content of the two brands. For wet dog foods, Blue Buffalo typically provides a little more fiber (about 2.16% more).

Blue Buffalo Cat Food vs. Holistic Select Cat Food

Dry Cat Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Crude Protein 38.8% 37.0%
Crude Fat 17.1% 18.1%
Crude Fiber 6.0% 4.3%
Wet/Canned Cat Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Crude Protein 46.8% 47.3%
Crude Fat 26.3% 30%
Crude Fiber 7.7% 4.5%

Crude Protein Comparison For Cat Food

Cats require twenty-two amino acids to sustain life. Eleven of these amino acids are synthesized naturally, the remaining eleven are consumed. Protein is the nutrient which provides some or all of these eleven essential amino acids.

Both brands provide roughly the same amount of crude protein. With regards to wet cat food, Holistic Select and Blue Buffalo also provide roughly the same amount of crude protein.


Crude Fat Comparison For Cat Food

There are many ways in which dietary fat contributes to the overall health of our feline friends. Here is a short list of benefits provided by fats (not exhaustive):

  • Help transport nutrients across cell membranes
  • Fats produce metabolites, which help control inflammation
  • Maintain healthy blood pressure
  • Slow the growth of yeast infections
  • Fats improve the taste/texture of food.

Blue Buffalo Pet Food Ingredients vs. Holistic Select Pet Food Ingredients

Blue Buffalo and Holistic Select both use the following controversial ingredients in many of their products:

Canola Oil

Here are some of the controversial ingredients used only by Blue Buffalo.

Garlic
Caramel
Pea Protein
Caramel Color
Tomato Pomace
Powdered Cellulose
Dried Tomato Pomace
Pea Protein Concentrate

Here are some of the controversial ingredients used only by Holistic Select.

Canola Oil (Preserved With Mixed Tocopherols)

We believe that certain pet food ingredients are linked to adverse health affects; these ingredients are classified as harmful.

Here are some of the harmful ingredients used only by Blue Buffalo.

Menadione Sodium Bisulfate Complex

Here are some of the harmful ingredients used only by Holistic Select.

Menadione Sodium Bisulfite

Product Safety: Recall History of Blue Buffalo & Holistic Select?

Blue Buffalo has been recalled 9 times.

  • Nov. 25, 2015: Salmonella
  • Nov. 6, 2015: Presence of Propylene Glycol
  • May 31, 2016: Mold
  • March 18, 2017: elevated beef throid hormone
  • Feb. 14, 2017: presence of aluminum
  • March 3, 2017: Foil Seal Packaging Problem
  • Oct. 8, 2010: toxic levels of vitamin D
  • April 19, 2007: Melamine
  • April 26, 2007: Melamine

According to our records, Holistic Select has never been recalled.

Price Comparison: Which Brand Is More Expensive?

Dry Dog Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Per Pound $2.75 $2.96
Per Calorie $0.0017 $0.0018
Dry Cat Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Per Pound $3.89 $4.31
Per Calorie $0.0023 $0.0025
Wet Dog Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Per Pound $4.30 $3.91
Per Calorie $0.0086 $0.0068
Wet Cat Food Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Per Pound $5.47 $5.85
Per Calorie $0.0106 $0.0099

The average cost-per-lb is heavily influenced by the varying amounts of moisture present in each brand's food products (wet vs. dry food, dry vs. freeze-dried food, etc). However, the average cost-per-kcal eliminates the influence of moisture. Therefore, the average cost-per-kcal is the better metric to consider.

If you'd like to calculate the average cost-per-day or cost-pet-year of feeding Blue Buffalo or Holistic Select, input your pet's weight into our cost analyzer widget.

Averages price data can identify whether or not there exists a significant price difference between two brands. However, the actual price that you'll pay for Blue Buffalo or Holistic Select will depend on your shopping habits.

Pet owners who use our price comparison feature typically save more than 25% off retail prices for Blue Buffalo and Holistic Select. In addition, we currently have some great coupons for our readers.


Disclosure: PawDiet has an affiliate relationship with stores featured (or linked-to) in this article. We are compensated for referring customers. Thank you for shopping with our retail partners!

Where To Buy Blue Buffalo Pet Foods

You can purchase Blue Buffalo pet foods from the following stores:


326 Recipes In-Stock Today

256 Recipes In-Stock Today

287 Recipes In-Stock Today

13 Recipes In-Stock Today

Where To Buy Holistic Select Pet Foods

You can purchase Holistic Select pet food products from these retailers:


30 Recipes In-Stock Today

26 Recipes In-Stock Today

30 Recipes In-Stock Today

Type Of Pet Foods Available

Product Blue Buffalo Holistic Select
Dry Dog Food 87 Recipes 16 Recipes
Wet Dog Food 99 Recipes 6 Recipes
Dog Treats 45 Treats
Dry Cat Food 42 Recipes 3 Recipes
Wet Cat Food 51 Recipes 5 Recipes
Cat Treats 17 Treats

Compare Pet Food Prices Across Multiple Pet Stores