Cheaper Alternatives Similar To Holistic Select

There are many pet food brands that are similar to Holistic Select. These affordable alternatives offer similar amounts of protein, fat, and fiber.

Our records also suggest that these substitutes for Holistic Select offer similar (or better) ingredients.

In other words, these brands are less expensive alternatives that provide a similar level of quality. On average, the brands we’ve selected for this list are cheaper than Holistic Select by 10% or more.

If you’d like to continue feeding Holistic Select, consider using our price comparison or sale section to save money on your next purchase.

What Type Of Pet Food Are You Looking For?

Disclosure: PawDiet has an affiliate relationship with stores featured (or linked-to) in this article. We are compensated for referring customers. Thank you for shopping with our retail partners! This article is updated regularly to maintain up-to-date information. All data is maintained internally.

Dog Food Similar To Holistic Select Dry Dog Food


Health Extension Dry Dog Foods

Health Extension offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $2.36 per pound. On average, Health Extension dry dog food is 20.21% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Health Extension, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Holistic Select dry dog food recipes contain an average of 0.19 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Dry Dog Food Holistic Select Health Extension
Crude Protein 31.4% 27.4%
Crude Fat 15.9% 16.2%
Price Per Pound $2.96 $2.36
Price Per kcal $0.00179 $0.00146
Avg Harmful 0 0
Avg Controversial 0.19 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Health Extension Dry Dog Foods.

  • Amazon: 2 Recipes In-Stock
  • PetFlow: 12 Recipes In-Stock
  • Chewy: 12 Recipes In-Stock
  • Health Extension Price Comparison

Dog Food Similar To Holistic Select Wet Dog Food


Pure Vita Wet Dog Foods

Pure Vita offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.37 per pound. On average, Pure Vita wet dog food is 13.77% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Pure Vita, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Holistic Select wet dog food recipes contain an average of 0.50 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Wet Dog Food Holistic Select Pure Vita
Crude Protein 53.8% 48.6%
Crude Fat 28.0% 33.6%
Price Per Pound $3.91 $3.37
Price Per kcal $0.00681 $0.00614
Avg Harmful 0 0
Avg Controversial 0.50 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Pure Vita Wet Dog Foods.

  • PetFlow: 3 Recipes In-Stock
  • Pure Vita Price Comparison

Cat Food Similar To Holistic Select Dry Cat Food


Nature's Logic Dry Cat Foods

Nature's Logic offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $3.50 per pound. On average, Nature's Logic dry cat food is 11.25% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Nature's Logic, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Holistic Select dry cat food recipes contain an average of 0.33 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Dry Cat Food Holistic Select Nature's Logic
Crude Protein 37.0% 41.8%
Crude Fat 18.1% 17.6%
Price Per Pound $3.95 $3.50
Price Per kcal $0.00231 $
Avg Harmful 0.33 0
Avg Controversial 0 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Nature's Logic Dry Cat Foods.

  • PetFlow: 1 Recipes In-Stock
  • Chewy: 4 Recipes In-Stock
  • Nature's Logic Price Comparison

Cat Food Similar To Holistic Select Wet Cat Food


American Journey Wet Cat Foods

American Journey offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.50 per pound. On average, American Journey wet cat food is 12.31% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by American Journey, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Holistic Select also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their wet cat food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Wet Cat Food Holistic Select American Journey
Crude Protein 47.3% 47.9%
Crude Fat 30% 23.9%
Price Per Pound $5.13 $4.50
Price Per kcal $0.00872 $0.01026
Avg Harmful 0 0
Avg Controversial 0 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock American Journey Wet Cat Foods.

  • Chewy: 11 Recipes In-Stock
  • American Journey Price Comparison

Redbarn Wet Cat Foods

Redbarn offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $3.78 per pound. On average, Redbarn wet cat food is 26.46% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Redbarn, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Holistic Select also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their wet cat food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Wet Cat Food Holistic Select Redbarn
Crude Protein 47.3% 46.8%
Crude Fat 30% 28.8%
Price Per Pound $5.13 $3.78
Price Per kcal $0.00872 $0.00790
Avg Harmful 0 0
Avg Controversial 0 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Redbarn Wet Cat Foods.

  • Chewy: 9 Recipes In-Stock
  • Redbarn Price Comparison

Taste of the Wild Wet Cat Foods

Taste of the Wild offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.23 per pound. On average, Taste of the Wild wet cat food is 17.61% cheaper than Holistic Select.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Taste of the Wild, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Holistic Select also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their wet cat food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

Wet Cat Food Holistic Select Taste of the Wild
Crude Protein 47.3% 44.4%
Crude Fat 30% 16.7%
Price Per Pound $5.13 $4.23
Price Per kcal $0.00872 $0.00988
Avg Harmful 0 0
Avg Controversial 0 0

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Taste of the Wild Wet Cat Foods.

  • Amazon: 2 Recipes In-Stock
  • PetFlow: 2 Recipes In-Stock
  • Only Natural Pet: 2 Recipes In-Stock
  • Chewy: 2 Recipes In-Stock
  • Taste of the Wild Price Comparison