Instinct Logo

Cheaper Instinct Alternatives


According to our research, there are many pet food brands that are similar to Instinct. In this article, you'll find multiple brands that offer comparable ingredients and maintain similar levels of macronutrients.

In addition, most of the brands listed in this article are less expensive alternatives. In fact, our research indicates that the recipes offered by these Instinct substitutes could potentially save you 10% or more on average.

If you’d like to continue feeding Instinct, consider using our price comparison or coupon section to save money on your next purchase.

What Type Of Pet Food Are You Looking For?

Disclosure: PawDiet has an affiliate relationship with stores featured (or linked-to) in this article. We are compensated for referring customers. Thank you for shopping with our retail partners!

Dog Food Similar To Instinct Dry Dog Food

Acana offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.57 per pound. On average, Acana dry dog food is 15.31% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Acana, we've computed an average of 0.04 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. These averages are less than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 1.11 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctAcana
Crude Protein
35.4%35.1%
Crude Fat
20.9%18.9%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$3.57
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00231
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.110.04

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Acana Dry Dog Foods.


Crave offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $2.37 per pound. On average, Crave dry dog food is 43.64% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Crave, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct dry dog food recipes contain an average of 1.11 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctCrave
Crude Protein
35.4%37.8%
Crude Fat
20.9%18.9%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$2.37
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00139
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.110

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Crave Dry Dog Foods.


Dr. Tim's offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $2.92 per pound. On average, Dr. Tim's dry dog food is 30.68% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Dr. Tim's, we've computed an average of 0.27 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. These averages are less than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 1.11 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctDr. Tim's
Crude Protein
35.4%34.5%
Crude Fat
20.9%19.8%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$2.92
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00178
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.110.27

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Dr. Tim's Dry Dog Foods.


I and Love and You offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $2.97 per pound. On average, I and Love and You dry dog food is 29.40% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by I and Love and You, we've computed an average of 1.09 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. These averages are less than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 1.11 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctI and Love and You
Crude Protein
35.4%34.4%
Crude Fat
20.9%16.4%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$2.97
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00186
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.111.09

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock I and Love and You Dry Dog Foods.


Nulo offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.65 per pound. On average, Nulo dry dog food is 13.35% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Nulo, we've computed an average of 0.17 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. These averages are less than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 1.11 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctNulo
Crude Protein
35.4%34.2%
Crude Fat
20.9%18.0%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$3.65
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00224
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.110.17

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Nulo Dry Dog Foods.


Wag offers comparable dry dog food recipes at an average cost of $2.62 per pound. On average, Wag dry dog food is 37.71% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry dog foods manufactured by Wag, we've computed an average of 1 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. These averages are less than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 1.11 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctWag
Crude Protein
35.4%39.1%
Crude Fat
20.9%16.9%
Price Per Pound
$4.21$2.62
Price Per kcal
$0.00218$0.00156
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
1.111

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Wag Dry Dog Foods.


Dog Food Similar To Instinct Wet Dog Food

Diamond offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.26 per pound. On average, Diamond wet dog food is 43.67% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Diamond, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet dog food recipes contain an average of 0.20 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctDiamond
Crude Protein
45.3%43.9%
Crude Fat
25.7%25.8%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$3.26
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00561
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Diamond Wet Dog Foods.


I and Love and You offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $5.15 per pound. On average, I and Love and You wet dog food is 11.02% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by I and Love and You, we've computed an average of 0.17 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 0.20 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctI and Love and You
Crude Protein
45.3%42.1%
Crude Fat
25.7%18.1%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$5.15
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00778
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200.17

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock I and Love and You Wet Dog Foods.


Solid Gold offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $4.35 per pound. On average, Solid Gold wet dog food is 24.76% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Solid Gold, we've computed an average of 0.23 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 0.20 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctSolid Gold
Crude Protein
45.3%41.8%
Crude Fat
25.7%24.8%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$4.35
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00945
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200.23

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Solid Gold Wet Dog Foods.


Stella and Chewy's offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $4.78 per pound. On average, Stella and Chewy's wet dog food is 17.41% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Stella and Chewy's, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet dog food recipes contain an average of 0.20 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctStella and Chewy's
Crude Protein
45.3%53.8%
Crude Fat
25.7%13.6%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$4.78
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.01382
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Stella and Chewy's Wet Dog Foods.


Taste of the Wild offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.47 per pound. On average, Taste of the Wild wet dog food is 40.09% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Taste of the Wild, we've computed an average of 0.20 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 0.20 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctTaste of the Wild
Crude Protein
45.3%45%
Crude Fat
25.7%20.6%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$3.47
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00850
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200.20

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Taste of the Wild Wet Dog Foods.


Victor offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $3.50 per pound. On average, Victor wet dog food is 39.59% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Victor, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet dog food recipes contain an average of 0.20 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctVictor
Crude Protein
45.3%43.0%
Crude Fat
25.7%29.4%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$3.50
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00771
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Victor Wet Dog Foods.


Zignature offers comparable wet dog food recipes at an average cost of $4.85 per pound. On average, Zignature wet dog food is 16.12% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet dog foods manufactured by Zignature, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet dog food recipes contain an average of 0.20 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctZignature
Crude Protein
45.3%43.4%
Crude Fat
25.7%28.0%
Price Per Pound
$5.79$4.85
Price Per kcal
$0.01147$0.00884
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.200

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Zignature Wet Dog Foods.


Dog Food Similar To Instinct Freeze-Dried (or Dehydrated) Dog Food

Note: References to freeze-dried products include dehydrated pet food products.

Sojos offers comparable freeze-dried (or dehydrated) dog food recipes at an average cost of $17.19 per pound. On average, Sojos freeze-dried dog food is 52.37% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all freeze-dried dog foods manufactured by Sojos, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Instinct also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their freeze-dried dog food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctSojos
Crude Protein
38.7%34.2%
Crude Fat
35.0%15.5%
Price Per Pound
$36.10$17.19
Price Per kcal
$0.01716$0.01033
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
00

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Sojos Freeze-Dried Dog Foods.


Tylee's offers comparable freeze-dried (or dehydrated) dog food recipes at an average cost of $26.52 per pound. On average, Tylee's freeze-dried dog food is 26.53% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all freeze-dried dog foods manufactured by Tylee's, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Instinct also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their freeze-dried dog food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctTylee's
Crude Protein
38.7%45.6%
Crude Fat
35.0%33.3%
Price Per Pound
$36.10$26.52
Price Per kcal
$0.01716$0.01170
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
00

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Tylee's Freeze-Dried Dog Foods.


Cat Food Similar To Instinct Dry Cat Food

Annamaet offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.24 per pound. On average, Annamaet dry cat food is 36.78% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Annamaet, we've computed an average of 1 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0.45 harmful, 1.10 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctAnnamaet
Crude Protein
44.4%42.2%
Crude Fat
21.6%18.9%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$4.24
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00241
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.101

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Annamaet Dry Cat Foods.


Crave offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $3.58 per pound. On average, Crave dry cat food is 46.67% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Crave, we've computed an average of 1 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0.45 harmful, 1.10 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctCrave
Crude Protein
44.4%44.7%
Crude Fat
21.6%19.6%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$3.58
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00210
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.101

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Crave Dry Cat Foods.


Essence offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.64 per pound. On average, Essence dry cat food is 30.76% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Essence, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct dry cat food recipes contain an average of 0.45 harmful ingredients and 1.10 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctEssence
Crude Protein
44.4%44.1%
Crude Fat
21.6%18.5%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$4.64
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00269
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.100

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Essence Dry Cat Foods.


Nature's Logic offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.83 per pound. On average, Nature's Logic dry cat food is 27.94% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Nature's Logic, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct dry cat food recipes contain an average of 0.45 harmful ingredients and 1.10 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctNature's Logic
Crude Protein
44.4%41.8%
Crude Fat
21.6%17.6%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$4.83
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00277
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.100

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Nature's Logic Dry Cat Foods.


Nulo offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.39 per pound. On average, Nulo dry cat food is 34.54% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Nulo, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct dry cat food recipes contain an average of 0.45 harmful ingredients and 1.10 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctNulo
Crude Protein
44.4%44.1%
Crude Fat
21.6%18.4%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$4.39
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00268
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.100

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Nulo Dry Cat Foods.


Tiki Cat offers comparable dry cat food recipes at an average cost of $5.99 per pound. On average, Tiki Cat dry cat food is 10.74% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all dry cat foods manufactured by Tiki Cat, we've computed an average of 0.60 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0.45 harmful, 1.10 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctTiki Cat
Crude Protein
44.4%46.2%
Crude Fat
21.6%20%
Price Per Pound
$6.71$5.99
Price Per kcal
$0.00351$0.00363
Avg. Harmful
0.450
Avg. Controversial
1.100.60

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Tiki Cat Dry Cat Foods.


Cat Food Similar To Instinct Wet Cat Food

Chicken Soup For The Soul offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $4.54 per pound. On average, Chicken Soup For The Soul wet cat food is 50.13% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Chicken Soup For The Soul, we've computed an average of 0.17 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 0.19 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctChicken Soup For The Soul
Crude Protein
48.6%49.8%
Crude Fat
23.2%26.4%
Price Per Pound
$9.11$4.54
Price Per kcal
$0.01897$0.00834
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.190.17

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Chicken Soup For The Soul Wet Cat Foods.


Fromm offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $7.32 per pound. On average, Fromm wet cat food is 19.64% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Fromm, we've computed an average of 0.13 controversial ingredients and zero harmful ingredients. Although the optimal average number of controversial ingredients is zero, these values are still lower than those computed for Instinct (0 harmful, 0.19 controversial).

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctFromm
Crude Protein
48.6%45.6%
Crude Fat
23.2%22.4%
Price Per Pound
$9.11$7.32
Price Per kcal
$0.01897$0.01765
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.190.13

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Fromm Wet Cat Foods.


Open Farm offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $7.83 per pound. On average, Open Farm wet cat food is 14.03% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Open Farm, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet cat food recipes contain an average of 0.19 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctOpen Farm
Crude Protein
48.6%43.5%
Crude Fat
23.2%29.2%
Price Per Pound
$9.11$7.83
Price Per kcal
$0.01897$0.01878
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.190

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Open Farm Wet Cat Foods.


Taste of the Wild offers comparable wet cat food recipes at an average cost of $5.72 per pound. On average, Taste of the Wild wet cat food is 37.20% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all wet cat foods manufactured by Taste of the Wild, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. On the other hand, Instinct wet cat food recipes contain an average of 0.19 harmful ingredients.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctTaste of the Wild
Crude Protein
48.6%44.4%
Crude Fat
23.2%16.7%
Price Per Pound
$9.11$5.72
Price Per kcal
$0.01897$0.01323
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
0.190

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock Taste of the Wild Wet Cat Foods.


Cat Food Similar To Instinct Freeze-Dried (or Dehydrated) Cat Food

Note: References to freeze-dried products include dehydrated pet food products.

The Honest Kitchen offers comparable freeze-dried (or dehydrated) cat food recipes at an average cost of $13.33 per pound. On average, The Honest Kitchen freeze-dried cat food is 64.76% cheaper than Instinct.

Considering all freeze-dried cat foods manufactured by The Honest Kitchen, we haven't found any harmful or controversial ingredients. Similarly, Instinct also doesn't appear to use any harmful or controversial ingredients in any of their freeze-dried cat food recipes.

If you'd like to read a detailed comparison and see an overview of all harmful and controversial ingredients, click here.

InstinctThe Honest Kitchen
Crude Protein
41.5%43.5%
Crude Fat
36.2%29.5%
Price Per Pound
$37.82$13.33
Price Per kcal
$0.01775$0.00660
Avg. Harmful
00
Avg. Controversial
00

Here is an up-to-date list of retailers who currently stock The Honest Kitchen Freeze-Dried Cat Foods.